On Remembering

On Remembering

For the peacemakers: Mandela, who walked out forgiving; Gandhi and King, who refused the easy weapon; Tutu and Gorbachev, who chose the seam over the wall; and the Dalai Lama, still patient. And for the three — those who serve, those who returned, and those who did not — who keep the peace by standing in the way of its breaking; and every unnamed soul who ever wanted it for the whole round world.

I

What is the earliest memory you have?

In On Growing I asked you this in relation to yourself (the person, the body, the small hand reaching for the world).¹ Today I ask it turned outward: what is the earliest memory you have of the world? The world arranged around you, with you somewhere inside it. The first time the room you stood in quietly became a planet.

Hold that. Let it sit a moment.

I have a bad memory. I’ll say that plainly. Whole years have gone soft at the edges, unlabeled, unrooted, gone. But there are points on my timeline that refuse to dissolve, and when I stand on one of them and turn slowly in place, I can see everything.² I can watch the events fan outward and feel how they moved through my life, and the lives of the people standing beside me.

1990 was a year on my timeline that resonated with me deeply, because of all the events that happened that year. This would explain why, in comparison to earlier memories, it stands out as a moment I can describe in great detail, as opposed to one I have no rooted necessity to explain.

That is the strange arithmetic of remembering. We do not keep the days we were told to keep. We keep the ones that resonated, the ones that hummed at exactly the right frequency to be saved.³ Each of those days is built out of Jays, my name for the smallest felt piece of a day: someone, something met, and a lean toward or away. Each Jay is lived once, by one person, and what we keep is what it leaves. What the true ones leave stays bright. What the ones that went wrong leave stays too, as lessons.

So let us test something together. My Quantum Lens looks at a moment the way you might look at a word, from more than one side at once, and leaves every reading standing (the physicists’ words are a picture here and nothing stronger). Seen through it, a moment is a superposition: many possible readings folded into one, waiting on an observer to collapse it into a single shape.⁴ I want to lift one year up to the light and let it collapse through your eyes. The mind of the reader.

Let’s take the year 1990, and explore it together.

II

The Cold War was ending. For more than four decades the world had been one thing held in two states at once: two futures stacked on a single planet, neither collapsed, both armed. In 1990 it began, at last, to choose.

And in the same year, in an office at CERN, Tim Berners-Lee served the first page from a single machine. December of 1990. The world outside was let in the next summer.⁵ The Web took its first breath in the very year an old war exhaled its last.

And we, being human, walked through the new door without checking what was on the other side.

Here is my theory, offered as theory and nothing more. The Web became a place for the mind to escape itself. Not the body. Itself. Every screen is a superposition: a thousand possible next things, each a thumb’s-width from becoming real. And we learned that we never had to choose. We could collapse one, and another, and another, forever, and never once let the world settle into a single shape. We called it scrolling. By 2026 we called it doomscrolling, and we said it like it was the weather.

The studies say the number of people living with a mental disorder has nearly doubled since 1990, and now runs past a billion. But read honestly, the same studies whisper a second thing: much of that growth tracks a larger and older population, and the rate per person has climbed far less than the totals.⁶ My own suspicion (and the people who study it are still arguing) is that the real spike is recent, and arrived with the glowing rectangle in every palm.⁷

So 1990 did not break us. 1990 only handed us the instrument that could. The seed and the bloom are not the same season.

III

Then, in February, they opened a cell in South Africa, and Nelson Mandela walked out into the sun.

I was told, as a child, that he died in there.

For years I carried two versions of one man and could not tell you which was true. This, I would learn, has a name. They call it the Mandela Effect, after this exact confusion, named by people who remembered a death that never happened.⁸

Apply the Lens here, and watch it fit like a key. A memory holds many possible pasts until someone settles on one. Most of us settle the same way and call the result reality, because each of us checks what we took in against what the people around us took in, and where the readings line up, the world feels solid.⁹ But sometimes a whole crowd collapses wrongly together, and the wrongness becomes load-bearing: real enough to build a life on.

Ask any child of the nineties about Shazaam, the movie where Sinbad played a genie. They will defend it with their whole chest. It does not exist. It never did. They are thinking of Kazaam. Shaq. 1996. The memory is so strong, so shared, that in 2017 Sinbad himself filmed fake footage of it. In the short, the little girl who frees the impossible genie insists that their memories are real, and that no one can take them away.¹⁰

That is the most timeless thing in this entire essay, and it is a joke.

If you can explain to me how that moment of collective insistence will not outlive the imaginary film it mourns, I will sit, and I will listen. I have time.

IV

In April, we launched a telescope into the dark to see farther than we ever had.

And we had built it blind.

Hubble’s great mirror was ground to the wrong shape. Not by much. By the width of a rumor. The instrument used to measure the mirror was itself misassembled, a spacing off by a millimeter and change, and so we polished the glass with perfect precision into a flaw. Other tests caught the error and were set aside, because we trusted the wrong instrument. We observed the heavens through a broken ruler, and collapsed them into blur.¹¹

Sit with that.

The reach for the stars was not misplaced. It was mis-measured. We aimed exactly where we meant to and checked our aim against an instrument we never thought to doubt.

And maybe the stress of that decade was partly this: the further the lens reached, the smaller the rock beneath us became. The “alpha” at the top of any human hierarchy is only an alpha while the territory stays small. Step off the spinning stone, and the whole pyramid of who-rules-whom evaporates into the cold. For everyone who thought they had it figured out, the nineties handed them a telescope and said, look how little you command.

That is a terrifying gift. Some never opened it.

V

In August, Iraqi troops crossed into Kuwait.

I remember my teacher crying. Day after day, in the church, she could not stop. Her husband had been asked to serve. I was small, and I did not understand the war, so my mind did what minds do. It took an entire collapsing region of the world and folded it down into the one thing I could hold: a woman’s shoulders, shaking.

That is how memory survives. It collapses the vast into the single point that resonated.

That was the year I learned, in my body before my mind, that war is not the answer to happiness. The world is destructive, and defense is necessary, until the day we all wake at once. I hold both. What separates defense from conquest is Intent, the way a hand faces when it moves, and I believe it changes what happens next. The act of crossing into another life over greed, over power, has never stopped ringing in me as wrong, at a frequency I cannot tune out.

So my heart goes out to the three. To those who serve. To those who served and returned. And to those who served and did not return. Until word comes, every soldier sent away is all three at once, a life held open by everyone who loves them and waits for them to come home. I have no words that compare to the selfless honor of an individual who would dedicate their life to the safety of their loved ones.

Your dedication to keeping this world free is unmatched anywhere in my life. I only pray that one day the people who lead you will see the world the way I am trying to see it now.

VI

In October, East and West Germany became one country again.

For forty-five years, Germany had been a single word with two readings: one people observed into two, held apart by a border that decided, every morning, which half you were (and, for twenty-eight of those years in Berlin, by a wall). In 1990 the two readings collapsed back into one. The seam closed.¹²

It was this, before any textbook, that first sent me down into the depth of the Second World War. Not as American history, or German, or Japanese, or English. As human history. A wound the whole species took in the 1940s, and a country that did not finish healing the seam until 1990.

In June 1990, slab by slab, they had begun pulling down the wall that was built through a people’s heart.

I hope every country does this one day. I hope we do it to the quieter walls, too: the borders we cannot see, the ones we carry between each other and call common sense.

VII

And in November, Margaret Thatcher walked out of power, as Mandela had walked out of prison nine months before. The year opened with a man freed and closed with a titan deposed.

She is the clearest superposition in the whole year, and here the Lens offers its mercy. Every observer collapses her differently, and each reading is honest; held up against one another, they make the only whole of her there is.

If you remember the woman who steadied a stalling nation and handed working families the keys to their own front doors, hold that. It is real, and it is a good thing to have seen. Your memory of your leader is an honest one.

And if you remember the one who stood unbending through the long ache of the mining towns, hold that too. It is real, and it is a good thing to have felt. Your memory of your leader is an honest one.

A life like hers leaves a Trace, my word for what a person’s intent goes on doing in the world after they have left it, and a Trace runs both ways at once. The front doors carry hers, and so do the pit villages. Mandela had twenty-seven years of reasons to turn his toward bitterness, and chose to forgive.

The Lens never asks you to surrender your reading for someone else’s. It asks only that you let theirs be as real to them as yours is to you. That is not weakness. That is the beginning of peace.

So here is my answer, since I asked you first. One of my earliest memories of the world is a woman’s shoulders, shaking, in a church, in 1990. Everything else in these pages is arranged around that one point.

Now find yours, and hold it carefully. To remember is to collapse. What we keep is the shape we collapsed it into, and that shape is what we hand on.

Right now some child is standing where I stood in that church, and the room is becoming a planet. They will take in the wars along with the peace. Whatever we do this year is somebody’s earliest memory of the world.

Make it one worth remembering.

Notes

1. On Growing opens on the same question and turns it inward, toward memories people report from birth and before it. Johnson, On Growing.

2. The psychologist Endel Tulving called this kind of remembering episodic memory: memory of one’s own experiences, each fixed to a time and a place, as distinct from the general store of facts he called semantic memory. He drew the distinction in 1972 and set it out at length a decade later. Tulving, Elements of Episodic Memory.

3. The resonance and the frequency are figures, not physics. That we keep what resonated rather than what we were told to keep is the ordinary experience of memory and also, roughly, what the research describes: the amygdala strengthens the consolidation of emotionally arousing experiences, so the days that stirred us are kept more firmly than the calm ones. McGaugh, “Amygdala Modulates.” Proust’s madeleine, the taste that returns a whole childhood unasked, is the literary portrait of the same keeping. Proust, Swann’s Way.

4. The superposition here is a figure and not a physical claim. The Quantum Lens itself collapses nothing; it holds the readings side by side. When attention or memory collapses something in these pages, that is a picture of many readings narrowed down to one, and no more than that. That an observer’s attention resolves a held state is a minority reading among the interpretations of quantum mechanics, associated with von Neumann and Wigner, and physics has not settled between them. What the essay needs is weaker and well established: memory is reconstructive, recall can reshape what is recalled, and two people can hold incompatible and sincerely held versions of the same event. Loftus, “Planting Misinformation”; Nader, Schafe, and LeDoux, “Fear Memories.”

5. By the end of 1990 Tim Berners-Lee had the first web server and browser running on a NeXT computer at CERN. He announced the software publicly in August 1991, and CERN released it royalty-free on April 30, 1993. Berners-Lee, Weaving the Web. One formal marker of the Cold War’s end is the Charter of Paris for a New Europe, signed in November 1990, at which thirty-four heads of state or government declared it over; the Soviet Union itself dissolved in December 1991.

6. The most recent Global Burden of Disease estimate puts the number of people living with a mental disorder at about 599 million in 1990 and 1.17 billion in 2023, an increase of about 95 percent. Over the same years the age-standardized prevalence rate rose about 24 percent. Because an age-standardized rate sets aside a population’s size and age, the gap between the two figures reflects a larger and older world. GBD 2023 Mental Disorder Collaborators, “Updated Trends.”

7. This is the author’s reading, not a finding. The case that smartphones and social media caused a rise in mental illness among the young is made by Haidt, Anxious Generation, and disputed by Odgers, “Great Rewiring,” who finds the evidence does not show it and notes that young people already struggling may simply use the platforms more. The clearest recent jump in the global data is the pandemic year: an estimated 27.6 percent more cases of major depressive disorder and 25.6 percent more cases of anxiety disorders in 2020 than expected. COVID-19 Mental Disorders Collaborators, “Global Prevalence and Burden.”

8. Fiona Broome, one of the people who coined the term around 2009–2010, had remembered Mandela dying in prison in the 1980s and found that others remembered the same thing. Broome, “Mandela Effect.” Mandela was released on February 11, 1990, and died on December 5, 2013.

9. The sociologist Maurice Halbwachs argued that even private memory is held within the frameworks of the groups a person belongs to, and is recalled through them. Halbwachs, On Collective Memory. That reality is each person’s reading checked against everyone else’s is the series’ own proposal.

10. Sinbad has repeatedly said he never made such a film. On April 1, 2017, CollegeHumor released “lost footage” of it, with Sinbad as the genie and the Mandela Effect as the joke. CollegeHumor, “Shazaam.” The film people remember is Kazaam (1996), starring Shaquille O’Neal.

11. The Hubble primary mirror was ground to a precise but incorrect figure because the null corrector used to test it was misassembled, with a spacing error of 1.3 millimeters. Other tests did indicate a problem and were discounted in favor of the instrument believed to be more accurate. The telescope launched on April 24, 1990; corrective optics were installed in December 1993. NASA, Optical Systems Failure Report.

12. Germany was divided into occupation zones in 1945 and into two states in 1949. The East German government began the Berlin Wall in August 1961, and it opened on November 9, 1989. East German border troops began its official demolition in June 1990, and the work was finished in 1994. Reunification took effect on October 3, 1990. The forty-five years count from the division of 1945.

Bibliography

Berners-Lee, Tim, with Mark Fischetti. Weaving the Web: The Original Design and Ultimate Destiny of the World Wide Web by Its Inventor. HarperSanFrancisco, 1999.

Broome, Fiona. “Mandela Effect.” Mandela Effect (website), 2009–. https://mandelaeffect.com/.

CollegeHumor. “Shazaam.” Online video featuring Sinbad. April 1, 2017.

COVID-19 Mental Disorders Collaborators. “Global Prevalence and Burden of Depressive and Anxiety Disorders in 204 Countries and Territories in 2020 Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic.” The Lancet 398, no. 10312 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)02143-7.

GBD 2023 Mental Disorder Collaborators. “Updated Trends in the Global Prevalence and Burden of Mental Disorders, 1990–2023: A Systematic Analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2023.” The Lancet 407, no. 10543 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(26)00519-2.

Haidt, Jonathan. The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness. Penguin Press, 2024.

Halbwachs, Maurice. On Collective Memory. Edited and translated by Lewis A. Coser. Heritage of Sociology. University of Chicago Press, 1992.

Johnson, Jamison Todd. On Growing. The On ——ing Series. Legible Traces, 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20731451.

Loftus, Elizabeth F. “Planting Misinformation in the Human Mind: A 30-Year Investigation of the Malleability of Memory.” Learning & Memory 12, no. 4 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1101/lm.94705.

McGaugh, James L. “The Amygdala Modulates the Consolidation of Memories of Emotionally Arousing Experiences.” Annual Review of Neuroscience 27 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.neuro.27.070203.144157.

Nader, Karim, Glenn E. Schafe, and Joseph E. LeDoux. “Fear Memories Require Protein Synthesis in the Amygdala for Reconsolidation after Retrieval.” Nature 406, no. 6797 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1038/35021052.

NASA. The Hubble Space Telescope Optical Systems Failure Report. NASA Technical Memorandum 103443. National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 1990.

Odgers, Candice L. “The Great Rewiring: Is Social Media Really behind an Epidemic of Teenage Mental Illness?” Nature 628, no. 8006 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-00902-2.

Proust, Marcel. Swann’s Way. Translated by C. K. Scott Moncrieff and Terence Kilmartin, revised by D. J. Enright. Vol. 1 of In Search of Lost Time. Modern Library, 1992. First published 1913.

Tulving, Endel. Elements of Episodic Memory. Oxford Psychology Series 2. Clarendon Press, 1983.

CC BY 4.0 · ORCID 0009-0009-8618-398X · DOIs MINTED ON DEPOSIT

© 2026 JAMISON TODD JOHNSON · LEGIBLE TRACES LLC